Why America doesn’t Build Tallest Building again

Chicago skyline
Skyline of Chicago, Willis Tower has been the tallest building in the city for more than 40 years.

America is the birthplace of skyscraper, in the last century, most skyscrapers in the world were located within America, New York City and Chicago had been the most notable skyscraper cities, and the crown of World's Tallest Building had always been retained by buildings in America, until in 1997 when Petronas Towers in Malaysia overtook that crown from Sears Tower with their decorative spires.

But after that, Asian countries keep building more and more skyscrapers, Dubai, China, and some Southeast Asian countries are best examples, as in recent years the majority of the newly built skyscrapers are located in these places. With the current pace, the total number of the skyscrapers above 500 feet in China will be 4 times of the number in America within a few years.

Moreover, many skyscrapers over 500 meters in height have been successfully built in China, while America's tallest building (by roof height) is the 472-meter-tall Central Park Tower, only 30 meters taller than the former tallest building Sears Tower, which was built in 1970s. America's official tallest building One World Trade Center is actually shorter than the Central Park Tower and Sears Tower without the antenna. Megatall skyscrapers are still in vision stage in America.

Tianjin CTF Binhai Center
The 1739ft-tall CTF Binhai Center in Tianjin, China

So why America doesn't build the tallest building again? Here are some major factors.

Technical Difficulties

Technical difficulties is actually not a problem to build higher, theoretically the maximum height that a skyscraper can be built is at least 1,200 m (4,000 ft), see the full explanation in this article. We don't need to worry about skyscrapers collapsing for they are built too tall, skyscrapers are much safer than low-rise buildings, most buildings collapsed are low-rise buildings, we've never heard a skyscraper naturally collapsed.

However, the problem is that in many American cities, the engineering standards is very rigorous, it becomes more difficult and expensive to adhere to those standards as the height of the skyscraper increases.
This is especially true in Los Angeles, which is located near the San Andreas fault line, it's even very hard to build a 1,000ft+ building there, for it's difficult to build that high under the city's rigorous engineering standards. For this reason, Wilshire Grand Center was first proposed with a roof height of 350m, but scaled down to a roof height of just 285m, and a more recent project called Angels Landing couldn't get approval with a proposed height of 310m, only to reduce its height to just 260m. Now the US Bank Tower is still the tallest building by roof height in the city.

Skyscrapers in Los Angeles
Skyscrapers in Los Angeles

Height Limitation imposed by the FAA

The United States has a rare nationwide height restriction on all kinds of man made structures. The FAA (Federal Aviation Administration) doesn't allow skyscrapers to be built higher than 2,000 ft in most cases to make the airlines more secure, and the restriction is even stricter in some cities in which the airports are built in close proximity to the city center, like in Seattle and Miami, skyscrapers generally can't be built to much higher than 1000 ft.

However, we can't blame FAA for the tallest building not being built in America, because 2,000 ft is still considered quite high, even Ping An Finance Center is only 1965 ft, and Shanghai Tower (the second tallest building in the world by roof height) is no more than 2000 ft if the height of parapet is not counted. We really can't blame the height restriction until some buildings close to 2000 ft get built in America.

Skyscrapers in America is allowed to be built 10 meters higher than Ping An Finance Center.
Ping An Finance Center in Shenzhen, China
Ping An Finance Center in Shenzhen, China

In Singapore, there's also a height restriction for buildings in CBD area, now the area has already have 4 buildings built exactly as tall as the height of restriction, only in this case the restriction can be blamed.

Additionally, in April 2020, China implemented a much stricter height restriction on skyscrapers, all the future skyscrapers built in the country are not allowed to exceed 500m.

Lack of Available Land

In China, the plots that many tall buildings are built on were mostly flat lands, for example, the skyscrapers in Pudong District in Shanghai, Yujiapu District and Xi Qing District in Tianjin.

As seen in the picture, the available land in Tianjin for skyscrapers is very abundant.

In American cities like New York City or Chicago, most land in the cities is already being occupied by existing buildings, to find a flat land (like a parking lot) for a new skyscraper is not easy, available flat land like Hudson Yards is in the minority, in most cases developers must first purchase the old buildings for the land, and then demolish them, higher buildings typically require larger bases, which means for developers to purchase more buildings (Before the construction on Sears Tower began, Sears bought a whole block of buildings to make space for the building). Technically they still can build tallest buildings, but the higher costs can potentially set back many developers.

New York City is filled with buildings.

Difficulties of Acquiring Air Rights

Furthermore, in some American cities like New York City, having acquired the land space doesn't ensure the developers to build as high as they want on it, since owning the land does not also owning all the air space above it. This is because under the zoning laws, every lot in the city has a maximum density restriction, which varies depending on which zoning district it's located in and some other factors. So by default the building on the lot cannot exceed a limited maximum height, which is affected by the density or floor area of the building, thinner building is less dense, hence allowed to be higher (this is why many pencil-like skyscrapers like 111 West 57th Street started emerging in the city).

Air rights is transferable, if the developer wants to build a building to their desired height that higher than the limit, they can purchase the unused air rights from the adjacent properties. But if they cannot afford it, or the owners of the adjacent properties refuse to sell the air rights (they might don't want their buildings to be dwarfed by a much taller tower, or it would block sun lights, etc.), or there's simply no enough remaining air rights around, they will fail to build a very tall skyscraper.

NIMBY & Approval

In some cities like San Francisco, shadow cast on nearby residential buildings can always prevent skyscrapers from being approved to be built higher. For instance, the Salesforce Tower was initially planned to be 370 meters tall but scaled down to only 326 meters due to the shadow issue.

In New York City, the shadow cast on Central Park by the newly built supertall towers on 57th street had sparked some protests. The Municipal Art Society is reported to be looking for a way to curtail New York City's supertall boom.

Donald Trump had ever planned to build a world's tallest skyscraper in New York City in 1985, named Television City Tower, the building was designed to be 1670 feet tall and would have 130 stories, it was planned to be built at the riverside on West 66th Street. Trump also had NBC signed as the anchor tenant for his building. However, some local community groups don't like the building and fought against Trump's proposal, making the proposal cancelled at last.

Donald Trump with the model of his proposed skyscraper Television City Tower.

In China, things is totally different, it is well known that the authorities can directly ask the nearby residents to move away to make place for a skyscraper, not to say protests for shadow cast.

No demands

Many people think that as a developed country, America has no demand for more skyscrapers. This is not really true, populations are growing, which means more houses and buildings need to be built to accommodate these new comers, that is why New York City is having so many supertall residential buildings being built.

No interest

In China and Middle East, one of the major motives for developing tallest buildings is to improve the prestige of a city. For America, many cities in the country are already pretty well known in the world, they do not need a tallest building to improve the reputation.

Chicago used to have some megatall proposals like Chicago Spire, World Trade Center, 7 South Dearborn, Post Office Twin Towers. Unfortunately the developers behind these projects are not big players in real estate.

Some giant technology companies such as Facebook and Apple prefer to build a campus as their headquarters, technology giants own supertall skyscrapers only happened in films, like in Amazing Spiderman, the headquarters of Oscorp is in a skyscraper named Oscorp Tower.

In June 2019, it was reported that Facebook is planning to develop a supertall tower in Midtown New York for its workspace in New York City. However not long after the news came out, a person with knowledge of the matter told Bloomberg that Facebook never seriously considered the building.

The proposed 'Facebook Tower'
The proposed 'Facebook Tower' would be located near the Empire State Building

Many large cooperation in the world believe that a very tall skyscraper may hurt their business, since this did happen in the past, one example is Sears, Sears Group was once the largest retail group in the world, after the Sears Tower got built, it was gradually surpassed by other companies like Walmart, at last Sears sold the building in 1990s. Hong Kong's real estate tycoon Li Ka-shing deliberately built the headquarters of his group shorter than the nearby Bank of China Tower.

Financial Difficulties

Financial difficulties is still the biggest enemy of the development of skyscrapers, especially in America where the labor is very expensive.
The former world's tallest building the Empire State Building was built in an era when labor was very cheap, most workers were immigrants, nowadays the construction workers in the United States are mostly local American.
Burj Khalifa in Dubai cost 1 billion dollars(1.5 billion dollars with its surrounding facilities) to build, in America, even 432 Park Ave, a building that is only about half as high as the former, cost more than this much.

Share this: